Only Murders In The Building Season 4’s Cast Updates Are Good News After Its Setting Change

While Only Murders In The Building season 4 promises a setting change, its cast updates prove that the mystery comedy series is still prioritizing consistency. Only Murders In The Building became a huge hit when the show debuted in 2021, but the light-hearted mystery series has only grown in popularity since then. Only Murders In The Building seasons 2 and 3 earned stellar reviews while adding a bevy of A-list talent to the show’s cast list, with stars like Paul Rudd, Mel Brooks, and Andrea Martin joining the lineup. However, the show’s biggest casting coup came in season 3’s Loretta Durkin.

The love interest of Martin Short’s Oliver, Loretta was a struggling actor played by Meryl Streep. Despite Streep’s considerable star power, she will return to the role in the upcoming Only Murders In The Building season 4. This is great news for the series, which promised a format shift at the end of its third season. Murder mystery shows rely on consistency more than many formats, with classic entries into the genre like Murder She Wrote and Columbo utilizing the same formula for countless episodes. However, Only Murders In The Building’s semi-serialized storytelling foreshadowed a potentially worrying location change.

Only Murders In The Building’s Cast Updates Prove It’s Committed To Consistency

The return cast is a smart decision

The heroes of Only Murders In The Building considered moving to LA at the end of the show’s third outing, a surprising twist that could have imperiled the show’s reliable setup. Luckily, Streep’s return means that Only Murders In The Building won’t be changing its status quo completely in season 4. The show isn’t forgetting about the storylines of previous seasons as Only Murders In The Building season 3’s ending will clearly have a meaningful impact on the next outing’s story judging by Streep’s comeback. Meanwhile, season 4’s other casting announcements are even more promising for viewers.

Not content with Streep’s return, Only Murders In The Building season 4 will also bring in new characters played by guest stars Eugene Levy and Eva Longoria. It is not yet clear who the Schitt’s Creek star and Desperate Housewives actor will play, but the fact that they have been cast proves that season 4 will still rely on new guest stars just like earlier seasons. Season 4 will also see Jane Lynch join the show’s cast although, like Rudd in Only Murders In The Building season 3, her role may be short-lived since she plays the season’s unfortunate victim.

Only Murders In The Building’s Latest Updates Are A Relief After Its Setting Change

The characters are more important than the place

While Only Murders In The Building season 4’s setting change is risky, the show’s new actors and its returning stars bode well for this outing. Moving the action of the series from LA to New York may end up being only a temporary switch-up, but continuing Loretta and Oliver’s storyline is particularly promising proof that the creators won’t be retconning the events of season 3. It isn’t too unusual for mystery shows to forget about characters after a murder has been solved, so Only Murders In The Building instead prioritizing consistency bodes well even as the series heads for a new setting.